- Android fit and software
- 8.6
- Health and fitness accuracy
- 7.6
- Battery life
- 7.0
- Value
- 7.0
1. Google Pixel Watch 5
Best for: Anyone on a recent Android phone, Samsung included, buying a first Pixel Watch or moving up from a Watch 3 or older.
Skip it if: You own a Pixel Watch 4, you want more than about two days per charge, or you need blood pressure and insulin resistance trends today.
Buy this if you want one watch that won't punish you for your phone choice. It works well with Pixel and Samsung phones, and what you lose away from a Pixel is small: improved smart replies and Proactive Suggestions. Expect a day and a half to two days per charge. Fast charging is the real win. Say you wake up at 15% with a run planned at lunch: about 45 minutes on the cradle fills it, so you barely notice the wait. Two things give us pause. Owners on Reddit are reporting a battery bug that cuts some watches to about 12 hours, so check whether a fix has landed before you buy. Gemini's raise-to-talk is also unreliable, so plan on pressing the button. Skip it if you own a Pixel Watch 4, which is nearly identical. If you see a new Watch 4 for less, we'd take that instead.
Reviews behind this pick
- Engadget (9/10): A very good, modest upgrade led by on-device Gemini, though Watch 4 owners need not upgrade.
- Droid Life (8/10): A polished watch and a worthwhile step up from early Pixel Watches, but skippable from the Watch 4.
- Expert Reviews: It does little wrong, but it sits too close to last year's model to justify full price.
- SlashGear: The reviewer's favorite smartwatch in its class, despite passive health insights and late features.
Pros
- Fast charging, about 45 minutes from empty
- On-device Gemini responds faster and works without a phone
- Light, with an attractive domed display
Cons
- Few hardware changes from the Pixel Watch 4
- Several health features arrived after launch
- Gemini raise-to-talk was inconsistent